Pine Hill Cemetery was established in 1842 as an inclusive cemetery that did not discriminate based on race, religion, or social status. Many notable people are buried there, including Governor Joseph B. Ely and Civil War veterans. The cemetery also has a scattering garden for cremated remains and a monument to honor the fallen soldiers. Pine Hill Cemetery is a peaceful and scenic place that reflects the diversity and history of Westfield.

The entrance to Pine Hill Cemetery is on Court Street.